• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

Bungled my first U.P. Buck

d_rek

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2014
Messages
2,495
Location
SELP Michigan
Thursday Nov. 15th found me tucked into a pop-up blind on 80 acres of fairly rugged land in Michigan's North-Central Upper Penninsula, in Marquette County, for the opening day of Michigan's General Firearms season. That Nov. 15th is something of a holiday in Michigan would be an understatement. It's kind of like Christmas, Thanksgiving, and Easter all rolled together. It's a special day, to say the least.

Marquette County is not known for having exceptionally high deer densities, being in the snowbelt part of the U.P. that sees an average snowfall of 220"+ inches a year and severe wintering conditions for wildlife. My expectations were realistic, if not lowered, than what I would typically expect hunting Southeast Michigan farm country and woodlots. So, as I was 3.5 hours into my opening day sit, I was pleasantly surprised when a very healthy looking doe came out of the pines approx. 30 yards to my left moving through a heavily trafficked pathway through the swamp my blind overlooked.

Less than 10 minutes laters I caught more movement and, to my amazement, a cruising buck came in nose to ground right on her trail. After a quick study of his rack I counted only 4 points and had to give him a pass as I did not have a tag for anything less than 3pt on one side or better. After the disappointment set in I decided to experiment with some calling. Having had some success with tending grunts a few hunts prior I grabbed the flexible grunt tube out of my pack and gave a couple soft tending grunts. To say the results were better than expected would be an understatement.

Almost immediately after grunting I saw the shape of a deer hoping back through the swamp towards my location. As it got closer I saw it was the same buck that had just moved through a moment ago. He was literally coming in on a string! As he got within 60 yards I put glass on him only to see that he had a set of browtines on each antler, making him a legal buck for me. I had already made up my mind to shoot the first legal buck that I saw on the 5 day trip we had. The gun was up, my scope on the deer, and I thumbed the hammer on the single action slug shotgun back in a few practised movements. In a few shorts seconds the buck had closed the gap form 60 to 30 yards but now was giving me a hard quartering toward me shot. He hung up for a brief second, only presenting a shoot to his sternum while staring at my blind, but quickly turned broadside and moved to 25 yards directly in front of my blind. A gimme shot if there ever was one.

Except that it wasn't. In the moment, between counting points, preparing for the shot, and watching this deer get within bow distance, my adrenaline dumped hard. My heart was racing, and while I don't recall being unsteady, I do remember flinching badly and punching the trigger, harmlessly putting a slug underneath the buck that gave me what should have been a guaranteed kill. The buck immediately bounded away into the cattails. He stared back at me before giving me a quick snort and running off in the direction the doe went in, never to show himself again for the duration of our hunting trip.

I was bummed to say the least.

It would be the only legal antlered buck our entire hunting party of 6 guys would see over the course of our 5 day trip. The landowner saw two moose (cows), we all kicked up snowshoe hare and grouse, and cut many deer and bobcat tracks in the fresh snow up there. It's a beautiful country and I could see myself easily getting lost in it. The next time I go up there will be whenever I pull a bear tag, as that's something i've wanted to hunt for a while now.
 
Man if that doesn't haunt your dreams I don't know what will.. I'm still re-living a lost world record grouper a few years ago in mexico. Its slightly less recurring now but still lingering.. One day we will have redemption.
 
Oh man, thats a tough day, but it sounds like a pretty cool place, thanks for sharing, sometimes I think when we get excited like that it's a little like flying in a really tight formation(Oh crap I'm really close to that other aircraft!), the best advice I ever got was to "wiggle your toes!" I couldn't believe it until I tried it, somehow it forces you to relax a little, I'm not sure if that will work on deer but I will probably try it if I find myself in a similar situation. I wonder if the archery range shot made you rush it a little thinking it was in the bag, I could see myself doing that. I'm also glad I don't hunt in Michigan, although I would like to experience a hunt up there sometime, the holiday thing has got to be pretty cool I imagine.
 
Cool experience. I would say that’s why it’s hunting not killing. Things happen and this was one of them. Keep you chin up and get back at em


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top