• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

Deer ducking bow shots

Doesn't matter where or what you shoot. Everything is situational.

I loosed an arrow at a doe at about 12 yards with my quietest bow....a 60# longbow pushing a 600 grain arrow. I center punched the heart.....on the opposite side I was shooting at.

Doesn't matter how quiet or how fast your bow is. It ain't quiet or fast enough for every situation.
 
I learned when A deer has his/her head down drinking , don’t shoot.
If the deer is on alert when they come in make it a close shot and shoot low,and a little forward let the deer duck into the shot
 

Here's another one circulated on this forum already, in case anyone interested missed it.
 
Buckhole75 said:
Most deer drop because they are alert plain and simple Gripes my behind to see these TV hunters meh calm deer to shoot and low and behold the deer reacts The worst part is that young guys see it and now every deer in the world drops LOL CMON MAN
Click to expand...
I always thought this way too but after some reflection I'm not sure the physics/math back up this statement. Just some food for thought.

The calculations below indicate that if a deer is walking at a very leisurely pace of 2mph it will walk further if not stopped than it can possibly drop due to the effect of gravity even if alert in the same arrow travel time. For instance, for my 270fps bow, and a 20 yd shot, if I don't stop the deer he'll cover 7.8 inches from the time I release the arrow to its arrival. In the same scenario, if I meh and stop the deer and he reacts instantaneous with the sound of the bow release he can only drop 5.5 inches maximum. The cross over to make stopping questionable occurs out around 30yds.

I included a similar chart for faster arrow speeds just for grins and that only extends the cross over distance.

1685372933118.png
 
arrowchukker said:
Sitting around today, watching some of the YouTube stars bow hunt deer. Now, a lot of things go into whether a deer ducks at a shot or not, but one thing I thought I noticed was deer in the open, like an Ag field, or the meadows of the mountain states, seemed to duck more often than say a deer shot in thicker woods/timber. Anyone else notice this?
Click to expand...

The more relaxed a deer is the less likely they are to duck.

A lot of youtubers give what I consider bad advice, which includes ALWAYS aiming as if the deer will drop at the shot. One guy said to always use the wrong pin (next pin up), which is crazy.

This might have something to do with these youtubers 1. being too anxious for a shot on camera and so shooting at alert deer, 2. them fidgeting with their camera gear and making the deer somewhat aware, and 3. how and where they set up to hunt.

If a deer is relaxed and is at 15 yards, I'm aiming exactly where I want the arrow to go.
 
I aim low...not low enough to miss vitals if no reaction but at the bottom edge anticipating some drop if we shooting off the ground and broadside. My arrow s.are pretty slow and try to compensate a little....id rather miss low than miss high.

Last year I missed a buck over the back. He was at 11yds and I was up 20 feet. I aimed almost below the entire body of the deer and that slippery joker still ducked it. He had no idea I was there. High angle shots are way hard to judge.
 
boyne bowhunter said:
I always thought this way too but after some reflection I'm not sure the physics/math back up this statement. Just some food for thought.

The calculations below indicate that if a deer is walking at a very leisurely pace of 2mph it will walk further if not stopped than it can possibly drop due to the effect of gravity even if alert in the same arrow travel time. For instance, for my 270fps bow, and a 20 yd shot, if I don't stop the deer he'll cover 7.8 inches from the time I release the arrow to its arrival. In the same scenario, if I meh and stop the deer and he reacts instantaneous with the sound of the bow release he can only drop 5.5 inches maximum. The cross over to make stopping questionable occurs out around 30yds.

I included a similar chart for faster arrow speeds just for grins and that only extends the cross over distance.

View attachment 85443
Click to expand...
Cant disagree with physics but i feel like when you are trying to predict the way and animal will react I would rather take my chances on the deer that is just doing his thing I dont want him knowing something aint right before i shoot
 
enkriss said:
You are never going to beat a deer’s reaction time with bow speed. Dont shoot at alert deer.

A quiet bow will help more than a fast one.
Click to expand...
Correct, shoot just under them and let 'em catch a broadhead in the riblets. Seriously, lots of folks I think fall in the trap of shooting at deer where the scoring rings are on a target.
 
The only correlation I've noticed is alert deer ducking far more often. I think mehhing is a terrible idea most of the time and way way overdone on youtube because of forcing shots to get them on camera.
 
elk yinzer said:
The only correlation I've noticed is alert deer ducking far more often. I think mehhing is a terrible idea most of the time and way way overdone on youtube because of forcing shots to get them on camera.
Click to expand...

also, young people/social contagion
 
I have never "stopped" a deer but have thought to myself that the "mehhing" noise was a weird choice if u are elevated in a tree... Wouldn't a bird or squirrel type sound be a better choice to get a deer to stop?

Edit: ooopppss I'm too slow. Mr crazy droptine brought it up while typing
 
DroptineKrazy said:
I've actually taken to using a kissing noise instead of the good old meh. Similar to calling in a fox the last 10 yards or calling to your cat. Seems to get a more curious response instead of an alert response. It has worked to perfection on the last several deer that I've shot.
Click to expand...

good call....I didn't get a shot on a nice 8 point this year because he was very close to the tree and so I tried a very low "meh".....It was cold and wet and I hadn't talked or cleared my throat in hours.....when I tried to do the micro-"meh".....no sound came out and he was out of my shooting lane a second later

kissing noise won't suffer from that and is volume adjustable

i didn't let out a full "meh" on that day because I was afraid he would bolt
 
I've had mixed results with noises. I don't do the meh noise any more for the reason @raisins said, I just whistle now. I've also yelled at bucks 30 yards away during the rut but its only worked twice out of the four times I've tried it. I think overall whether its ducking or trying to get a deer to stop it's all based off of their personality.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top