• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

Do you tie off your saddle to the end of your tether?

Do you tie in to the end of your tether?

  • Yes

    Votes: 46 46.0%
  • No

    Votes: 54 54.0%

  • Total voters
    100
Ok everyone, the problem with you backing up by tying into one linesman loop is that when the fall occurs, the most likely outcome would be that the loop violently spins you sideways/face first while it breaks and drops you. Very few saddles have linesman loops capable of arresting a fall when used properly, let alone arresting a fall from only one connection. Want to know what I mean? Look at some of these rated eye to eye cords that you use for distel or VT hitches. When hooked in straight pull the rating is much much lower that when hooked in basket configuration. Your linesman loops are essentially the same. They work in basket configuration and split the force between the two connection points. If you’re tied into one side, it will be almost scary how quickly your flipped and the eye snaps so you now fall face first instead of backwards. They are not designed to catch you. The only saddles I know of that has true continuous loop for a thing off to would be the phantom and the new aerohunter saddles. Aerohunter sews theirs all the way around flat to the mesh BUT it does not attach to the safety belt so you most likely would still fall as the mesh or cordura ripped. On the phantom the continuous loop is bar tacked into the top and bottom which is strong but many of those bartacks would be pulling against the direction of the fall so many of them would bust. Of all the saddles, that’s the only one I think would possibly hold you as your back up connection point. *** On another note*** if you have a fall that is severe enough to break your friction hitch/ or your bridge (initial connection point) you have generated enough force that you’re most likely dead, or so badly injured that you would wish you were dead. So even if that secondary connection did hold you, it would be holding a dead or permanently paralyzed person in that tree. And it would not be holding you face up to help recover. I know all of this sounds harsh. But at 1800 lbs of force your body suffers potentially life ending injury. If you broke a friction hitch or a bridge that holds at over 3000 lbs, then you’ve well surpassed that 1800 lbs of force. Just some food for thought. I believe firmly in safety. But unless you’re wearing a secondary tether, or keeping on your linesman rope as the secondary connection, then you aren’t doing anything that will truly save you. That is why I personally don’t worry about tying my tether into my linesman loop or back to my bridge.
And for the record, your work has something to do with working aloft or the tree industry, right? Certainly not trying to be smart... your position on this and comments you've made in other threads leads me to believe you are trained/take regular training on matters related to working with ropes at altitude.
 
I wear a belt that is climbing rated webbing and a Cobra buckle with metal D ring. I tie the end of my tether to the D-ring. But then I also use my linesman rope as a parallel tether that is attached to the D ring too. Is it over kill? Yes, but I'm a firm believer that any 'back up' system cannot share any single point of failure as the main system. It take a few extra minutes to setup, but I do not notice the 2nd/backup system at all, which is one of the main point, that you do not know that it is there. To fall completely out of the tree, 2 of the same part of both systems need to fail which means Murphy came for me and there is nothing more I can do.
What belt are you using?
 
I have an 8 foot tether. I have two prussics on it. The lower one is connected to my bridge with a biner. The upper works as a stopper to keep my tether tight to the tree. I run the tag end of my tether through both bridge loops and back up to the top prussic. It sounds like alot but if my bridge were to fail my tether running through my bridge loops would catch me. It also gets rid of that excess tether swinging around doing nothing.
 
And for the record, your work has something to do with working aloft or the tree industry, right? Certainly not trying to be smart... your position on this and comments you've made in other threads leads me to believe you are trained/take regular training on matters related to working with ropes at altitude.
Yes sir. I keep the lights on ;) although we do not use ropes for climbing, we use a belt/webbing with a cinch style pole lock similar to a buck squeeze.
I also know for fact currently there are no standards in place for saddles, I’ve also seen what some people are calling linesman loops. How they are sewn, the direction of a fall and how the thread is pulled against. The strength of the eye, all of that plays factors in what would happen from being tied into a single linesman loop. Even the d ring on your riggers belt. It’s designed to use as a tie in point for an emergency rappelling situation, they are not designed to catch your fall because literally every bit of force would be applied to your back/waist. There is a reason that OSHA and ANSI have limits on the amount of force that Fall arrest systems can generate. That reason is anything beyond that force will cause life threatening injuries. You do not have to believe me, however there is plenty of information available in forms of studies. ASTM, ANSI, OSHA and many tree climber organizations release reports, regulation explanations and studies.
 
There are many sobering realities coming to light for me with saddle hunting. This is just another one…it’s adorable to think you are helping yourself by tying a backup into one of your linesman loops..
 
So the jar from being tied in a lineman’s loop worse than hitting the ground?
 
And for the record, your work has something to do with working aloft or the tree industry, right? Certainly not trying to be smart... your position on this and comments you've made in other threads leads me to believe you are trained/take regular training on matters related to working with ropes at altitude.
However Mr Beard, I am not a technical trainer. I am not telling someone not be safe, I am just being honest. Part of work positioning safety is understanding how force is applied and most likely outcomes from different fall factors/distances. This is why all manufacturers say keep your system taut (tight). Saddles are not designed to arrest a fall they are designed to restrain a fall. Have you ever seen a person or even a dummy fall a couple feet in a saddle? The amount of force generated in such a short distance is down right scary. And it’s not evenly distributed. You are not kept upright. Many of you are very experienced saddle hunters. I am not telling you or other members what to do. I’m not a trainer, I cannot give you a certificate saying you’re a safe climber. I can only tell you my “opinions” based on my experiences and first hand knowledge. Will any of you ever experience a fall bad enough to break your bridge? Statistically no. Am I saying not to tie in a secondary if it gives you a piece of mind? No!
I am saying for all of you that use mechanical ascenders, the break rating on those are much much lower than you realize and if you fall on one and you’re tied off at the bottom of your tether, then you have done nothing to help your self. Mechanical rope grabs are made to hold your rope advancements, they are not made to sustain fall arrest. Ok my two cents is over. Just be safe, keep your system tight so that you minimize your risk of falling and keep any potential fall distance to a minimum as well. All hunting is dangerous. You wouldn’t go out and just shoot your muzzleloader without cleaning it some, making sure your powder is backed all the way down, would you? You wouldn’t purposely shoot a bow with badly worn strings? It’s the same with saddles. Understand what they are designed to do and use them as intended. Inspect them and your ropes. If you’re unsure what is unsafe, find someone who is qualified to inspect them for you. Keep your system tight and you are as safe as you would be while doing any other hunting related activity.
 
So the jar from being tied in a lineman’s loop worse than hitting the ground?
The jar alone? Potentially. The jar from the linesman loop breaking because only one side of your system is taking the force instead of both side of the system? Well then you’re still most likely hitting the ground
 
It would be cool to see actual independent testing of saddles...only one I have ever seen is the guy from H2 testing the triad bridge
There are several companies out there that have videos of independent testing being done, I haven’t seen any showing their linesman loops being tested though because that would be a brutal drop, that I doubt many would pass
 
However Mr Beard, I am not a technical trainer. I am not telling someone not be safe, I am just being honest. Part of work positioning safety is understanding how force is applied and most likely outcomes from different fall factors/distances. This is why all manufacturers say keep your system taut (tight). Saddles are not designed to arrest a fall they are designed to restrain a fall. Have you ever seen a person or even a dummy fall a couple feet in a saddle? The amount of force generated in such a short distance is down right scary. And it’s not evenly distributed. You are not kept upright. Many of you are very experienced saddle hunters. I am not telling you or other members what to do. I’m not a trainer, I cannot give you a certificate saying you’re a safe climber. I can only tell you my “opinions” based on my experiences and first hand knowledge. Will any of you ever experience a fall bad enough to break your bridge? Statistically no. Am I saying not to tie in a secondary if it gives you a piece of mind? No!
I am saying for all of you that use mechanical ascenders, the break rating on those are much much lower than you realize and if you fall on one and you’re tied off at the bottom of your tether, then you have done nothing to help your self. Mechanical rope grabs are made to hold your rope advancements, they are not made to sustain fall arrest. Ok my two cents is over. Just be safe, keep your system tight so that you minimize your risk of falling and keep any potential fall distance to a minimum as well. All hunting is dangerous. You wouldn’t go out and just shoot your muzzleloader without cleaning it some, making sure your powder is backed all the way down, would you? You wouldn’t purposely shoot a bow with badly worn strings? It’s the same with saddles. Understand what they are designed to do and use them as intended. Inspect them and your ropes. If you’re unsure what is unsafe, find someone who is qualified to inspect them for you. Keep your system tight and you are as safe as you would be while doing any other hunting related activity.
Oh no bud. Not trying to trap you at all! Like @kyler1945, just trying to point out that here at SH, we suffer greatly from speculation and assumptions. It's good to have a trained voice speaking into our conversations.
 
I am referring to using a dynamoter and a system to cause a static pull to see at what poundage stuff breaksE5FB7F05-ACDA-44F7-B768-4EEC4EF94753.jpeg
 
If you had a fall that broke the rip stop material or the amsteel to allow you to fall and that centralized waist belt d ring is what caught you, aren’t you worried that your spine would be severed and your insides mangled?
Not really. I would be if I was only wearing the belt. The belt has leg loops too which spread out the force. With my dynamic rope and screamer in line my worst case scenario force applied should be less than 1 KN.
 
But that’s the thing, these saddles are not fall arrest devices and so any independent testing is pretty much moot. If you are not always keeping tension in your tether you are using the saddle incorrectly.
Facts! You are 100% correct sir. The only testing criteria available is the standards for full body fall arrest harnesses. Which are in fact designed to catch you in a fall. It’s still nice to see testing done to show your saddle is strong. However I think we would all be blown away with the forces produced.
 
I
Not some yah-who bouncing around in a saddle
I was referring to 3rd party certified testing labs that use meters to measure force and drop certified weights from certified measurable distances. I don’t count static pulls as direct correlations to dynamic loading either
 
Back
Top