• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

Milkweed Alternative

Boone Liane

Active Member
SH Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2024
Messages
179
Milkweed is wildly popular as a windicator, and rightly so.

But, what do you use if milkweed is a rarity, or nonexistent in your area? Buy it? Nah.

Get a rabbit!

I use white jackrabbit hair (but cottontail belly fur works just as well).

Get a nice winter jackrabbit and start plucking. I like the belly hair as it’s finer but any hair off the jack will work.

Form and lightly roll this hair into sort of a rope and stuff it into a container. I like the old 35mm film containers, if you can find them.

Only downfall to hair is it tends to want to stick to gloves. But so does milkweed in my experience.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4549.jpeg
    IMG_4549.jpeg
    352.7 KB · Views: 24
  • IMG_4550.jpeg
    IMG_4550.jpeg
    226.3 KB · Views: 24
I’m actually planting milkweed this this fall. Google says they need a good frost to propagate in the spring. I hope it works out.
 
Goose down works too.1lb is fairly cheap and should last a few seasons.
 
Marabou feathers work very well as a substitute for milkweed. You can also get them dyed in bright easy to see colors. Also the fluffy part of the body feather from a turkey makes a good substitute.
 
Turkey down works well, but ya gotta put some effort into the process.
 
Back in the day, you were warned not to use milkweed as it could spread seeds that were unwanted.

Wind-checkers such as @Black Titan posted work just as well, as does marabou.

I also like commercial wind checker powders, which are usually gypsum. Don't try to substitute DIY corn starch unless you are poverty-stricken, as it is heavier and doesn't work as well.

Wind-checker powders or a frayed length of dental floss tied to your bow stabilizer or elsewhere at your stand position give you immediate feedback of what the breeze is doing at launch range.

I like wind-checkers (other than milkweed) to see what things might look like at "bow range."
 
I sprinkled some milkweed seeds last year and have about 5 plants that have pods this year. Considering i still have some leftover from last year, I'll be set for a while. I always remove the seeds when i use it.i tried the powders and didnt like them. Great for right where you are, but thats about it.

I was in walmart yesterday getting my licenses and saw seedless milkweed in a dispenser for sale, so thats an option for those that don't have it growing locally too.
 
I’ll mail you some milkweed pods if you wanna give me your address in a PM.
 
Back in the day, you were warned not to use milkweed as it could spread seeds that were unwanted.

Wind-checkers such as @Black Titan posted work just as well, as does marabou.

I also like commercial wind checker powders, which are usually gypsum. Don't try to substitute DIY corn starch unless you are poverty-stricken, as it is heavier and doesn't work as well.

Wind-checker powders or a frayed length of dental floss tied to your bow stabilizer or elsewhere at your stand position give you immediate feedback of what the breeze is doing at launch range.

I like wind-checkers (other than milkweed) to see what things might look like at "bow range."
I use the powder when im "running and gunning" on the ground still hunting or spot and stalking.

But its pretty useless from a stand to tell you what the currents are doing even just 10 foot away.
 
I sprinkled some milkweed seeds last year and have about 5 plants that have pods this year. Considering i still have some leftover from last year, I'll be set for a while. I always remove the seeds when i use it.i tried the powders and didnt like them. Great for right where you are, but thats about it.

I was in walmart yesterday getting my licenses and saw seedless milkweed in a dispenser for sale, so thats an option for those that don't have it growing locally too.
How many seed did it take for 5 plants? I have hundreds of seeds collected from separating them from the fluff and I’m debating how much to try and sow. Says they need to be planted in the fall to experience a frost for them to grow in the spring. I’m not going to over think it though, I’ll probably throw a bunch and see what happens.
 
How many seed did it take for 5 plants? I have hundreds of seeds collected from separating them from the fluff and I’m debating how much to try and sow. Says they need to be planted in the fall to experience a frost for them to grow in the spring. I’m not going to over think it though, I’ll probably throw a bunch and see what happens.

We got a bunch of free seeds from the state to plant. Something about saving the butterflies or whatever. They sent us a few pouches but they never grew.

BT
 
How many seed did it take for 5 plants? I have hundreds of seeds collected from separating them from the fluff and I’m debating how much to try and sow. Says they need to be planted in the fall to experience a frost for them to grow in the spring. I’m not going to over think it though, I’ll probably throw a bunch and see what happens.
I threw a hand full from the pods i found out in the field last year. I have a "food plot" in my backyard that i planted a few years ago. Now it's more natural growth than anything, and a lot of the wild life uses it. So i just tossed them in there last fall to see what would happen.

A plus, i had a lot of butterflies this year!
 
Ok, 5 was an understatement. Most plants, if they had pods, had at most 2. This one has a bunch. I collected this off of 4 plants.

I might need to see if EWO needs a milkweed supplier...
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20261004_143831_Gallery.jpg
    Screenshot_20261004_143831_Gallery.jpg
    1,004.7 KB · Views: 8
  • Screenshot_20261004_143740_Gallery.jpg
    Screenshot_20261004_143740_Gallery.jpg
    597.3 KB · Views: 8
  • Screenshot_20261004_143728_Gallery.jpg
    Screenshot_20261004_143728_Gallery.jpg
    965.4 KB · Views: 8
Ok, 5 was an understatement. Most plants, if they had pods, had at most 2. This one has a bunch. I collected this off of 4 plants.

I might need to see if EWO needs a milkweed supplier...
I wait until they turn a light yellow before I pick the pods off. That way they naturally dry and just barely start to open. Easier to harvest the inside.

Am I doing this wrong? Or does everyone pull em early?
 
Back
Top