This is true, but the right wind doesn't mean your perfectly down wind. What hunting the wind means to me is the wind that provides you the best opportunity for the area you want to get into. There are so many factors that go into hunting mature deer that you can screw it up by missing any one of them.
I would like to point something out. All of my posts are my opinions, it almost feels as though some maybe trying to "justify" why they do what they do. Not one of should ever feel the need to defend why they hunt the they way they do. Styles are infinitely personal, what works for one may not benefit another. I am very proud to say that I do things different, and I am also pretty proud of the community we have here. We do things different, if it works for you do it. If someone else says that they think your are wrong for that, well you can give that the attention it deserves! I for one am thankful for the wealth of knowledge and the endless different approaches to hunting SH provides!