As others have mentioned, it’s really personal preference. I prefer the Tethrd ES OG as it holds everything I need in one package The two side pockets hold my MadRock/biner and Dynaglide, while the main holds 40’ of Canyon C-IV. Top of the bag is a little floppy, but I found that if I bias my coils around my figure 8 to the bottom end, it just slides right in with no fuss. If you get one or the other and don’t like it, it’s easy enough to switch without too much expense as this rabbit hole is much shallower than the saddle/sticks hole. Ha, ha! If you go the roll pouch route, Beaston is da man!. Good Luck!