Right now I have a couple phantoms, a kite, and a jx3.
Comfort is subjective but being comfortable enough is very important to me. I’ll trade a little comfort for stealth, weight, and ease of use but I won’t be uncomfortable.
Weight isn’t as big an issue as being able to wear it in. If course all things being equal the lighter it is the better it should wear in. I can’t stand having to pull up my saddle every few steps all the way to the tree. There’s always suspenders but I’ve found with the right saddle they aren’t necessary.
I’ve got to feel safe in it. For you that may mean every buckle, strap, stitch and camo pattern needs to be climbing rated. For others that may mean a homemade saddle with plastic buckles. You have to evaluate the risks you are willing to take. You need to include an assessment of your size, fitness level, and climbing method to help make those decisions. When in doubt its better to have a saddle that’s been tested.
I want it to be quiet. I intend to spend some time in the ess and treehopper sling this spring but really don’t see me adding metal to my setup unless they offer an almost magical comfort improvement. I’m already comfortable enough in a saddle that’s lighter, quieter, and wears in better.