I just went through this, trying to figure out what I wanted. I love the idea of the doyles, but don't want the weight. Looked at that Allen's, and too many bad reviews. Looked at different dog leashes, and they were all also heavy.
I ended up going with the HSS hoist. No, it's not auto retrieve, but I think it should work ok. Gotta be better than the 40ft of dyneema I use now. That stuff tangles so easy and wraps around everything it touches. Love it for a pull down rope, but hate pulling up my bow on it.
BT