• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

An evidence based gear system

RedOak

Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
94
Location
Upstate NY
The following posts are going to be in depth reviews of the gear that I have found to be extremely effective for me in the area and style which I hunt. Before I detail the gear, I feel it’s a good idea to give everyone some background on myself.

I am a 32 year old male from upstate NY. I currently hunt around 10 different properties consisting of ag fields/woodlots, swamps, suburban/wildland interface. All properties are either public or free permission. I do not have exclusive access or control of any of the properties and the pressure on most of them and the surrounding land is substantial. At this point in my career, I am targeting mature bucks only (4.5 years old and older).

I have been bow hunting since 2011 and have logged a substantial amount of time in the woods due to my work schedule. I am currently a professional firefighter and prior to that, Marine infantry with two combat tours. I believe in hard use, multipurpose, minimalist gear. I have no brand loyalties and will use whatever product/camo pattern I believe works best for me.

I am 5’8” tall and 160lbs. I work out regularly and would say I have a muscular build for my height. My Levis jeans are sized 32x30 and I wear a medium or large T-shirt depending on cut for reference.

Ill break my gear down by season and layering in the following posts and will try to provide pictures too at some point.

Early season (October 1st-31st):

-Sitka gear core lightweight hoodie- This shirt keeps me cool during those early October evenings and the zippered front allows me to vent heat on my walk in. The hood is a nice feature if it’s still buggy out that time of year. I don’t use the facemask portion of the shirt as I don’t feel I need it given the height and amount of leaves still on the trees.

-Carhartt Forces Extreme Cargo Pant- Not camo, nothing sexy about these. They are just well fitting, quick drying, durable and abrasion resistant pants that have just the right amount of pocket space. They are light enough to remain cool opening week and solid enough to carry me through mid October without having to add a merino wool base layer. They are fitted enough that they will not snag on my gears of my bike if I’m riding in and they dry quickly if I’m kayaking to my location and they water from paddling gets on me. The tapered ankle tucks in well inside my boots as well. I have had many fancier and more expensive pants from Kuiu and Sitka that I didn’t think were as durable or comfortable as these. My Kuiu attack pants were not abrasion resistant and were quite tore up after only a season. I am not bushwhacking in these things and was not thrilled with their performance. I do still own a pair of Kuiu Tiburon pants which I wear kayak fishing but feel they are not substantial enough for bow hunting season after season.

-Sitka Stratus Jacket- This is my do all piece. If you can only buy one jacket for all your hunting needs, this would be it. I have owned (and sold), just about every jacket Kuiu and Sitka make and this thing is the cats ass. The windstopper is an absolute must have for me. It’s warm without being bulky, its quiet, and it has a pretty minimalist approach. This jacket, when layered properly, can take me through the entire season here in upstate NY. In early October this jacket stays in my pack until I need it once the temp drops in the evening. I add this over my core hoodie and warm and comfortable until mid-late October.

-Xtratuf 15” Legacy Boot- These boots are incredibly lightweight on your feet and comfortable. With a normal sock they are excellent early season and when the temp drops I simply add merino wool socks and they will take me into late October. The tread pattern isn’t very aggressive but they are more than adequate for all my bow hunting needs. If anything, the lack of an over the top aggressive tread doesn’t allow them to collect large amounts of mud and weigh down while walking in.

-Kuiu Icon cap- This hat just happens to fit me great and is made of an awesome material that manages to keep my head cool and the sun out of my eyes. It dries quickly and that’s about all I can ask for.

-Hill People Gear Umlindi Backpack- If you guys aren’t familiar with these guys you need to check them out. Their forum is loaded with good backcountry information rooted in real world experience. They don’t just talk about, they are about it. I own several of their products and cannot say enough good things about them. FirstSpear does all their sewing and they are a top notch tactical gear producer. In fact, the micro adjusters on the new Mantis look almost identical to some of the adjustment pieces on their packs. This particular pack is very minimalist in nature. There are really only 4 pockets. Two outside bottle pockets I use to carry my piss bottle and hold my 3 arrow Tight Spot quiver on the other side. The main pocket is where I store a small Nalgene (mostly for a tickly throat to keep me from coughing), a small incidentals bag which I’ll detail later, any layers I don’t want to wear walking in, or rain gear, and me linemans belt and tree tether. There is a small pouch near the top of the main compartment where I put my keys in and eventually a grunt call later in the season.

-5.11 TDU 1.5” belt- This belt is nice and low profile for wear under a saddle or rock climbing harness. I may try the Hill People Gear “Under Pack Belt” at some point. Its closure system eliminates the standard buckle and may prove even more comfortable under a saddle.

-Sitka bino harness- I prefer the less is more approach Sitka has taken with this harness. I’ve had several others that were either too much elastic and bounced around or too much work to get the binos out. I bring the cap for the eyepieces and leave it in my pack unless it starts raining at which point I’ll put it on.

-Vortex Viper 10x42 binos- These things are awesome and I have no idea how guys can hunt without binos. Just because I might not be able to shoot a deer doesn’t mean I don’t want to know who he is, where he’s going, and any other actionable intel I may be able to gather with a good pair of binos. They are absolutely mission critical to me. They let me scout an area without ever having to step foot in it. They are especially important for my early season observation sits. They allow me to pinpoint locations I can use to later ambush a particular buck based off of his entrance into a field. They are also great for shed hunting and summer scouting from the Truck. These things can take a beating and I think Vortex no fault policy warranty is unmatched.

-Vortex Ranger 1000- I like the size and the belt clip on these. They can stay in a pocket or clipped to my saddle. Also small enough to stick in my breast pocket on the Stratus jacket. These serve dual purpose for long range rifle shooting as well.
 
I carry an S&S Precision “lockout” for my milkweed. It’s essentially a fancy Skoal can. But it holds enough milkweed for an entire season just about and it fits perfectly in any pant pocket allowing me to be able to easily check the wind without having to reach into my pack and still sit comfortably in my stand or saddle.
 
Good stuff, I like the way your reviews are written. I'd never heard of Xtratuf boots, due for a new pair of rubbers and I think I am going to check those out. I like the price.
 
Mid-season to Late-season (Nov1st – mid December)

My mid-season starts typically on Halloween. This is when I switch from hunting evenings only to hunting mornings and evenings. I follow this pattern unless I have trail camera evidence to suggest mature bucks moving in daylight. This time of year the mornings can be below freezing temps and can warm up or remain the same. The weather can be very unpredictable during mid-season. Once November hits, I will try to sit as much as often as possible for as long as possible rain or shine. This means I need a system which will perform in a wide variety of conditions and be modular enough to adapt on stand/saddle.

My systems builds off of the items included in my preview “Early Season” post and adds the following:

Smartwool Merino 250 base layers- This set includes both the shirt and pants. It’s one of the most highly regarded base layers reviewed on many, many websites. It’s versatile, warm, moisture wicking, and scent free. I have them in black, as all base layers designed to retain heat should be.

Kuiu Peloton 200 Zip T-Hoodie- This pairs awesome with the Smartwool top and adds a good amount of warmth under the Stratus jacket. I like the hood because its low profile and keeps my neck warm and adds extra warmth to my head without obstructing vision and hearing. It interfaces really well with my other layers.

-Patagonia Mens Down Sweater- I just added this piece this year so I cannot speak on it too much yet but I can tell you why I chose this item and what I replaced. I sold my Sitka Fanatic vest and got this instead because I wear this vest under my Stratus jacket and it allows me to add a low profile warming layer without any redundant features. The Stratus jacket and fanatic vest both have windstopper which I don’t need double of. Also, the fanatic vests best feature was the built in hand warmer muff. That feature doesn’t interface with a saddle however rendering it additional useless bulk to me. I am not concerned about wind/water resistance with this layer as it is going to be protected by my out layer (stratus). Another nice feature of this vest is its ability to pack down into its breast pocket making it extremely packable and taking up almost no room in my pack on my walk in.

-Sitka Stratus Bibs- These are new this year and not yet available. I sold my Stratus pants to purchase the bibs which I anticipate being nearly identical except not having a waist belt to deal with. To me, this is ideal for saddle hunting as I am eliminating one more buckle and some not needed bulk. The Stratus pants were simply awesome and I’m confident the bibs will not disappoint. A quick note on the Stratus system: I owned the Kuiu Guide Series jacket and pants previously and found them to be pretty mediocre for stand hunting. If I was hunting out west and stand hunting and on a budget, I would strongly consider the Kuiu system, but for a dedicated stand/saddle system, Sitka is the clear winner. It should be noted that the Kuiu system was also never designed for the stationary nature of stand/saddle hunting. I have also owned the Sitka Fanatic jacket and bibs and found those to be an awesome system but far too warm to walk in with and too bulky to pack in. They also had a limited period of use which was too short for my liking. Layered correctly, the Stratus serious will do everything the Fanatic does and more.

-Muck Arctic pro boots- The best cold weather boot I’ve found. These combined with the right sock are a game changer and I have yet to get cold in them. Make sure you get the “Pro” model and not the “sport”.

-Smartwool Hunter Extreme socks- Top of the line cold weather socks. These things paired with the Muck boots are amazing. When you’re done hunting, leave them out on top of your gear box and they will dry out and be ready to hunt again the next morning without needing a wash every time. Anytime someone wants to get me a Christmas gift, I ask for these and am now well stocked.

-Stormy Kromer Original Hat- Looks kinda goofy but its wool and keeps my head warm and dry. A brim is a must have for me to keep the sun out of my eyes, especially in early rut mornings. The ear flap can go up and down to regulate heat and doesn’t impede my hearing. Pair this with the Kuiu hoodie’s hood and my head is plenty warm down below freezing. I just have one in gray. The deer haven’t seen me yet.

-Sitka Fanatic Glove- Good lightweight glove that leaves the tip of my pointer and thumb open for using my iphone and being able to maintain good contact with the trigger on my release. I have tried a lot of gloves and once I’m actually in a tree, these are hard to beat.

FHF Gear MOLLE-Muff- Since I got rid of the Fanatic vest and its built in hand warmer pouch, this is a must have. It fits perfectly over a saddle allowing me to keep my hands warm and out of the elements while hunting. It’s a thousand times better than sticking them in my pockets once the temp drops and it has a built in chemical heater pouch. This lets me get away with no gloves or when it’s really cold, the Fanatic gloves. Also, the pouch allows me to keep my phone easily accessible and warm so that the battery doesn’t drain as quickly.

-Sitka Downpour Jacket/Pants- I will be ordering these with the Stratus bibs in a week. These will replace my Kuiu Yukon gear which I found to be overkill for what I do. The Kuiu was amazing stuff but I think my application just wasn’t right for it. I think the Downpour, being purpose built for stand hunting, will be a better fit. If there’s interest, I’ll do a review of it later on during the season.

I have a few other small items I keep in my pack that I will write up once I get home. I also keep a mid sized container with an assortment of items in my truck throughout the entire season as well. I will detail what’s in it and why later.
 
Xtraruf aren’t very popular outside of Alaska. But if you watch just about any show on Alaska where there are guys hunting and fishing, check out their boots and I guarantee you 9 out of 10 guys are wearing xtraruf’s. I’m a fan of mine and am on my second pair. The more worn out pair are not my trail camera checking boots.
Good stuff, I like the way your reviews are written. I'd never heard of Xtratuf boots, due for a new pair of rubbers and I think I am going to check those out. I like the price.
 
I should also note that the owner of FHF Gear, Paul, is a great guy and LEO in Bozeman. Myself and two other firemen went to Montana shed hunting and got in contact with him prior to our arrival. We found him only after purchasing some products and realized since he was in the area we would be, we might as well try emailing him for some advice on where to stay/eat. He was awesome and gave plenty of recommendations and even invited us to his home to check out some of his projects he was working on at the time. An all around great guy and someone well worth doing business with.
 
Back
Top