• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

Dumb Luck

neonomad

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2019
Messages
1,373
Many many times it’s better to be lucky than good. Statistically I killed better deer when I was dumber. Do you have stories of success in spite of obvious poor tactics?

I’ll start. In 2010 I was sitting upwind of a trail into doe bedding. I grunted this buck in from downwind (on that trail), and perfect heart shot him with a bow that was 1.5” too short in draw length for me. He ran maybe 40 yards. Back then I remember being so proud of the shot but now that I look at this picture, I’m real lucky the Spitfire found a soft spot.

There’s no better time to make a bunch of dumb moves than the next two weeks, in my opinion.
C52A218E-959E-4D58-A077-FF31A6855529.jpeg
 
16 years old, sitting in a boxed in tower stand at a creek junction overlooking two soybean fields on the afternoon of opening day of rifle season. Fell asleep and woke up about an hour before dark. Looked around, saw empty fields in both directions and hit the grunt call. 145" main frame ten walks out of the creek into the soybeans at 75 yards looking for the buck that grunted. Dropped him with a spine shot and wasn't convinced I hadn't dreamed about there being a big buck in the field til I walked over to him. Biggest deer I've ever killed.

Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk
 
when I was 14 years old, I had a friend who had a black bear compound bow that was barely legal draw weight. He didn’t use it, so I begged my parents to buy it for me. After flinging Walmart arrows at a bale of straw with a paper plate attached to it for about a week, I felt “confident” enough to kill a deer. I knew nothing about archery, and less about deer hunting. My father (only killing 1 deer in his life at the time) decided he would show me a “good spot”. As we walked to the top of a hill overlooking a creek, he preached the entire way “don’t step on any sticks or leaves, if there are deer in the creek you’ll scare them”. Being mid November, of course I stepped on a twig that snapped and of course there were deer in the creek, and of course they took off. My father got mad, stormed out of the woods, jumped in the truck and left my butt standing there in the woods with my bow in hand. With nowhere to go, I decided to walk the edge of the woods in the direction the deer went. After covering half the length of the woods, I caught a glimpse of deer coming out of the woods across the cut bean field (probably 300 yards away). In my mind, if I tucked a few feet into the woods next to me… these deer may just wonder over towards me and I may just get an opportunity to fling an arrow at one. I’m standing there, leaning up against a tree watching these deer make absolutely no attempt to head my direction for about 30 min. All of the sudden, I heard something walking up behind me through the woods that sounded like a dog. I slowly turned around, fully expecting to see a dog… nope. It was a HUGE yearling doe that must have shaken her spots off 50ft further back in the woods, and she was walking right towards me with her head down. I slowly pulled the bow back, and when she got to around 10 steps away, she cut 90 degrees and exposed her “paper plate”. I let that arrow fly, and heard for the first time a sound that I’ve learned to love and appreciate over the years. She disappeared behind some brush ,and I heard a crash about 30 yards through the woods. For me, a little luck went a long ways for me that night. That was my very first deer, and the beginning of a lifelong addiction that I’m still battling 27 years later. I have come a long ways since then, although I admittedly still rely on some degree of luck in the deer woods. If only they had cell phones or I had a drivers license back then… it would have saved me the mile hike to the nearest house after dark so I could call for a ride home for myself and my 60 lb trophy.
 
Last edited:
First year bow hunting in a ladder stand I draw and release an arrow at a doe not 20 yards away. Somehow I failed to notice the branch jutting out and saw it deflect the arrow, and the twig bouncing after the shot. I get down and check anyway and find one drop of blood and some hair stuck in the mechanical head. I went to where I last saw the deer and with each bound it seems the blood has sprayed more and more until its gushing. The deer made it about 50 yards and when I got to it discovered the arrow had deflected and slit it's jugular. Lucky.
 
Question for anybody that might know, in my original post here, the deer was slight quartered towards… is that entrance wound slightly behind the heavy shoulder bones?
 
If anything. Deer can be totally un predictable. My buddy at work was sitting with his daughter Saturday. She wanted to go a little after 9. So she left and went back to the house. Less than 5 minutes later nice buck comes walking up, and he shoots it. Per all the things we think, that never should have happened. But it does. You can do lots to stake it in your favor. But sometimes you need a little "luck" to close the deal..
 
If only I had some luck because when your like me and you have no luck or skill you dont get to lay many deer flat.
 
I feel that 90% of big bucks are killed by dumb luck and the fact they were actually in the woods hunting. You can't kill them from the couch. Luck will only take you so far. The other 10% are killed by a lot of hard work or by having a lot of money and someone else doing the work for you.
 
Back
Top