I have the opportunity to buy an older Trophyline saddle, the one with the leather seat. Not 100% sure on what year it is, but it's new in the package and reasonably priced. However, I'm wondering if I'll end up wanting something newer/better in a year anyway. Anyone else been in this situation?
-
The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
-
We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules
Is an older saddle worth it?
- Thread starter lardy125
- Start date
The leather trophyline are regarded by many as the creme de la creme of soft saddles. Not the lightest, but comfy. I'd say go for it.
Honestly friend, everyone is in this situation. You'll find that everybody here is in search of "newer/better" gear. Welcome aboard!
cmbetke
Well-Known Member
DIY a setup and see if you like the whole idea. I'm taking that route before I decide to drop a few hundred bucks on just a saddle set up.
Sweet, thanks for the feedback. Looks like I'm gonna get a saddle then, lol!
You make a great point, I should have thought of that. I'm always looking for stuff I "need" too, lol!
KelvinM12
Active Member
A saddle, accessories, climbing method, etc., are all "to each his own." People have their own personal preferences and strong convictions based on knowledge and experience, but even those preferences seem to change over time, lol. I've sat in a leather trophyline but don't own one... yet. Can you provide me the link to the one you're considering?
Kidding! Couldn't resist.
They are very comfortable, but are heavier and could be warmer to the rear in warmer weather. My advice is to try as many different saddles (and other gear) that you can, and make the best decision you can in the moment. So what if you find a better saddle to your liking down the road. Get another one then! The saddle's not going to be the difference in a successful hunt.
Enjoy the journey!
ImThere
Well-Known Member
if its cheap, leather and new there is absolutely no way I would pass it up, especially if its a large, if its a large and you don't like it remember me! lol
My advice to anyone new to saddles is if you find a steal of a deal, get it, you can always get your $ back if you under pay. If not, get a rock climbing harness, a yard or two of fleece or ripstop nylon, a rated tether and linesman rope, some rated carabiners, some rope for a bridge and you are set with a very comfortable starter package on the cheap. You can also make a simple Anderson knockoff (search for Wraptor, components readily available at doublesteps.com) for less than $60. Either of these or a used saddle will get you started, but as @KelvinM12 said, butt time in as many saddles as you can try is the key. Meet with others in your area, go to Saddlepalooza or a local gathering and sit in all the latest and greatest, as well as the classics. Each of us like different a feeling in the saddle, what works for me may feel cruddy to you. I would not run out and buy commercial saddle just based on reading here about them until you know what you will like best and have put hands on them. Don't get intimidated by all the components and think this is too complex either. It all boils down to a few straps, some rope, something to get up the tree, and practicing safe techniques.
lol! It's leather, new, aaannnd....medium. Sorry mate!
No problem flipping that particular saddle as described. You’ll probably end up w/ a few & then hoarding your favorites!
d_rek
Well-Known Member
I hated the trophyline saddles too uncomfortable for me... but some people love them. I'd say the newer ones are leaps and bounds more comfortable... but if the price is right i'd say go for it. Biggest drawback of the trophyline is the bulk. Should be able to break even if you don't like it and end up selling it.
Good to hear the other side of the story too, thanks for chiming in! The price is $150, which seems okay for an unused (literally unopened package) saddle, even if it is a bit older?
Buy it, try it! If you like it, your Golden. If you don't, flip it and your Golden
Yeah, good point. Just confirmed that I do want it, hopefully be able to pick it up next week!
KelvinM12
Active Member
Brilliant!