ricky racer
Well-Known Member
The interest in warm clothing has waned a bit since the hunting season has come to an end for most of us at least in the northern reigns of the country. Nonetheless I wanted to give my observations on cold weather clothing of which I don't claim to be an expert. However, I've been around for a long time and have tried a lot of gear. I've had everything from Damart "Laugh at the cold" base layers (old timers will remember those) to down filled coveralls but always was working with a tight budget. That being said, I have no problem spending money on good gear while trying to find a way to buy it at bargain prices.
You all know I'm a Wiggy's fan and swear by his Jacket Liner and Vest Liner. From my experience there is not a better liner on the market at any price to wear as part of a layering system for keeping warm. This past year I purchased a First Lite Woodbury jacket from a member here. I got a great deal on an almost new jacket that still had tags. I was excited to try the jacket out but it was too heavy of a jacket to wear until the end of November. The Woodbury jacket is well made and has a lot of well thought out features. The material is fairly quiet, not as quiet as my favorite outer layer, the old Winona knit camo (again, old timers will know what that is) but still fairly quiet.
The Woodbury jacket is very heavy in physical weight even heavier than a heavy weight Sleeping Indian wool jacket I've got. I haven't weighed it but my guess is it probably weighs between 8 & 10 lbs. What really surprised me about the Woodbury is the insulation. The insulation medium is a First Lite exclusive called 37.5 Technology of which they offer no information as to what it is. First Lite claims "that 37.5 breathes at a rate that is anywhere from 50% to 300% better than any of its competition, while offering waterproof levels that were within a 5% tolerance of our competition." I don't know how they can claim that. The jacket is warm but I can't do anything physically in it without sweating to death. I read on here all the time about guys carrying their clothing out to their trees before getting dressed and climbing to their hunting height. I never understood why anyone would do that until I wore the Woodbury. Wearing it, I sweat like a pig and I'm soaked by the time I get to my stand location. It's like wearing a garbage bag over your base layers then throwing the jacket over the bag, much like you'd expect a jacket with Goretex or some windblocker membrane in it to react to perspiration. The reason I chose the Woodbury is it didn't have a membrane in it. If it would have had a membrane, I would have never purchased it. The Woodbury jacket is also too bulky to even think about stuffing into a backpack for carrying.
Now I'm not knocking the Woodbury or First Lite products, it's just not what I'm used to. I'm used to good quality gear that has very good vapor permeability. I had Wiggy custom make a jacket liner for me using his L6 Lamilite insulation (he only charged me $100 for it) that is easily as warm as the Woodbury, weighs a fraction of the Woodbury and I can wear it while walking out to my stand with the jacket partially unzipped without sweating to death. I don't wear it much because it's not often cold enough to need it during the Michigan hunting season. If I have to carry the Wiggy's liner, it compresses down easily and will fit in a small backpack. I generally wear the lighter weight jacket liner and can easily stuff the vest liner into my small pack to add if needed.
This is just an observation and I'm only telling you what has worked for me. I've never tried Sitka gear due to cost and Goretex linings and I don't ever see me trying it. Maybe it's good stuff. The Woodbury is a nice jacket if you don't mind carrying it to and from your stand and the temperatures are in the lower 20's. I love the Cipher camo pattern First Lite uses. Will I keep it or send it on down the road? I don't know time will tell I guess...
You all know I'm a Wiggy's fan and swear by his Jacket Liner and Vest Liner. From my experience there is not a better liner on the market at any price to wear as part of a layering system for keeping warm. This past year I purchased a First Lite Woodbury jacket from a member here. I got a great deal on an almost new jacket that still had tags. I was excited to try the jacket out but it was too heavy of a jacket to wear until the end of November. The Woodbury jacket is well made and has a lot of well thought out features. The material is fairly quiet, not as quiet as my favorite outer layer, the old Winona knit camo (again, old timers will know what that is) but still fairly quiet.
The Woodbury jacket is very heavy in physical weight even heavier than a heavy weight Sleeping Indian wool jacket I've got. I haven't weighed it but my guess is it probably weighs between 8 & 10 lbs. What really surprised me about the Woodbury is the insulation. The insulation medium is a First Lite exclusive called 37.5 Technology of which they offer no information as to what it is. First Lite claims "that 37.5 breathes at a rate that is anywhere from 50% to 300% better than any of its competition, while offering waterproof levels that were within a 5% tolerance of our competition." I don't know how they can claim that. The jacket is warm but I can't do anything physically in it without sweating to death. I read on here all the time about guys carrying their clothing out to their trees before getting dressed and climbing to their hunting height. I never understood why anyone would do that until I wore the Woodbury. Wearing it, I sweat like a pig and I'm soaked by the time I get to my stand location. It's like wearing a garbage bag over your base layers then throwing the jacket over the bag, much like you'd expect a jacket with Goretex or some windblocker membrane in it to react to perspiration. The reason I chose the Woodbury is it didn't have a membrane in it. If it would have had a membrane, I would have never purchased it. The Woodbury jacket is also too bulky to even think about stuffing into a backpack for carrying.
Now I'm not knocking the Woodbury or First Lite products, it's just not what I'm used to. I'm used to good quality gear that has very good vapor permeability. I had Wiggy custom make a jacket liner for me using his L6 Lamilite insulation (he only charged me $100 for it) that is easily as warm as the Woodbury, weighs a fraction of the Woodbury and I can wear it while walking out to my stand with the jacket partially unzipped without sweating to death. I don't wear it much because it's not often cold enough to need it during the Michigan hunting season. If I have to carry the Wiggy's liner, it compresses down easily and will fit in a small backpack. I generally wear the lighter weight jacket liner and can easily stuff the vest liner into my small pack to add if needed.
This is just an observation and I'm only telling you what has worked for me. I've never tried Sitka gear due to cost and Goretex linings and I don't ever see me trying it. Maybe it's good stuff. The Woodbury is a nice jacket if you don't mind carrying it to and from your stand and the temperatures are in the lower 20's. I love the Cipher camo pattern First Lite uses. Will I keep it or send it on down the road? I don't know time will tell I guess...
Last edited: