Before making the switch to the saddle, I also used tree stands with lifelines. Since I hunt private property with presets, I set them up with lifelines for saddle hunting as well. I agree that the Muddy ropes are junk like most of their products. However, I am too cheap to throw them away. Instead, I removed their prussic and replaced it with a DIY distel hitch and some accessory cord. Since it releases easier than the prussic, the sheath does not bunch up as bad. It works better, but it does not change what the Muddy rope is.
I also have four of the Hunter’s Safety Systems ropes and love them. They have the reflective material woven into the rope, and it looks like a neon hotel sign when you hit it with a flashlight. Midway USA has a three pack of them for $99.99. I don’t think that you can do better than that with DIY rope options. I am experimenting with retying the HSS prussic with a Schwabisch on one of my HSS ropes, and it seems to work very well. It looks like it is going to be much easier to move the Schwabisch up and down the rope. From the options that I have used and looked at, the HSS three pack is what I would recommend.