• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

The Piled-High Club

Good info here guys. Thank you for responding.

My question is do any of you alter your personal diet during the hunting season?
Absolutely not, except for coffee on the morning of a hunt, if it's early. I typically won't drink coffee before an early morning hunt, and if it's an all day sit, no coffee period (unless I'm hiking, then I may stop and make a cup). I also don't eat much except for supper anyway (inside or outside of hunting season), but maybe a few snacks in the tree if it's chilly out.
 
Would you please describe areas of no use to deer? I've heard it said before to be on the lookout for saddles, pinch points, etc. when reviewing topo maps and satellite imagery but I've never really thought about negating areas because they'd be of little use to a deer.
Josh Driver, a guest on the southern outdoorsmen podcast phrased it the best way I have heard, eliminate the negative terrain. Think about it from the standpoint of what deer need and how they will get from one spot to another as well as when they might use an area. You might find a white oak with a lot of feed sign but if that tree is not close to cover, the odds start going down to see daylight activity there. Big areas of mature timber with little to no ground cover are the same. If there is not a mast tree dropping, there is no reason for a deer to be there in daylight, generally speaking. Then add to that looking at what terrain and/or vegetation features are going to influence where deer travel moving from bed to food and back and how bucks will move across the landscape checking does during pre-rut and rut. There are certainly spots in negative terrain where you can kill deer, the objective though is to focus on the highest odds spots of daylight movement that condense travel for the highest odds for a shot opportunity. If I am e-scouting, I am looking for hard edges, soft edges, and terrain features. Then when I am boots on the ground scouting, I am looking at all available food and deer level cover. The more features you can stack in a spot, the better it likely will be.

The spot I hunted this weekend was an area I have never hunted before on a WMA I hunted for a long time. I applied exactly this approach. This is big "flat" river bottoms. There were 3 parallel ridges (1.5' high ish) running NE to SW that junctioned into a N/S ridge. The "high" ground is narrow high stem count thickets and at the junction was a few big nutall oaks, a couple over cups and a giant water oak. The water oak and one nutall were the 2 primary feed trees. So in this spot there was hard mast, lots of browse, multiple soft edges and multiple terrain features but the two primary feed trees were 15-20 yards apart in a 50-60 yard area. I hung on the downwind side of the nutall. Friday I had 2 different 8's come through one moving NE to SW and the other on the N/S line both passed by inside 20 yards. For the trip I had 5 different shot opps on deer inside 20 just not the type deer I was after.
 
Last edited:
Absolutely not, except for coffee on the morning of a hunt, if it's early. I typically won't drink coffee before an early morning hunt, and if it's an all day sit, no coffee period (unless I'm hiking, then I may stop and make a cup). I also don't eat much except for supper anyway (inside or outside of hunting season), but maybe a few snacks in the tree if it's chilly out.
Coffee is a weird thing...or maybe I'm just weird or just too young yet lol. Effects people differently. I defintely dont get the coffee jitters either. Did an all day sit saturday and had 2 cups before I left for the woods and put the rest of the pot in two travel mugs. Drank the 30oz mug in the stand a few sips out of the EWO mug towards the end. Never did have to take a bathroom break though I felt one was coming the last few hours and still didnt go till I got home around 7pm
 
Josh Driver, a guest on the southern outdoorsmen podcast phrased it the best way I have heard, eliminate the negative terrain. Think about it from the standpoint of what deer need and how they will get from one spot to another as well as when they might use an area. You might find a white oak with a lot of feed sign but if that tree is not close to cover, the odds start going down to see daylight activity there. Big areas of mature timber with little to no ground cover are the same. If there is not a mast tree dropping, there is no reason for a deer to be there in daylight, generally speaking. Then add to that looking at what terrain and/or vegetation features are going to influence where deer travel moving from bed to food and back and how bucks will move across the landscape checking does during pre-rut and rut. There are certainly spots in negative terrain where you can kill deer, the objective though is to focus on the highest odds spots of daylight movement that condense travel for the highest odds for a shot opportunity. If I am e-scouting, I am looking for hard edges, soft edges, and terrain features. Then when I am boots on the ground scouting, I am looking at all available food and deer level cover. The more features you can stack in a spot, the better it likely will be.

The spot I hunted this weekend was an area I have never hunted before on a WMA I hunted for a long time. I applied exactly this approach. This is big "flat" river bottoms. There were 3 parallel ridges (1.5' high ish) running NE to SW that junctioned into a N/S ridge. The "high" ground is narrow high stem count thickets and at the junction was a few big nutall oaks, a couple over cups and a giant water oak. The water oak and one nutall were the 2 primary feed trees. So in this spot there was hard mast, lots of browse, multiple soft edges and multiple terrain features but the two primary feed trees were 15-20 yards apart in a 50-60 yard area. I hung on the downwind side of the nutall. Friday I had 2 different 8's come through one moving NE to SW and the other on the N/S line both passed by inside 20 yards. For the trip I had 5 different shot opps on deer inside 20 just not the type deer I was after.
This is perfect. Thank you. I'm going to reread this a few times. To me this equates to don't just setup where you see steaming poop. Deer poop all the time. Instead, look around and see if the poop corresponds with a bunch of edibles in the area.
 
This is perfect. Thank you. I'm going to reread this a few times. To me this equates to don't just setup where you see steaming poop. Deer poop all the time. Instead, look around and see if the poop corresponds with a bunch of edibles in the area.
Deer poop all the time, yes. But they only poop where they are walking. Poop is just one type of sign too. Tracks tell a story, browse sign tells a story, browse species tells a story, and you have rubs and scrapes too. More than one way to skin the cat though. You can look for sign and then evaluate why it's there or you can scout features and confirm with sign. I was taught to hunt following the first method but feel the second option is more efficient. Using both helps a lot. All of this though is just about the where. Still have to nail down the when and that is going to be influenced by the time of season, pressure, weather and moon, imo. It also matters if you are just deer hunting or trying to kill a mature buck or a specific buck.
 
Coffee is a weird thing...or maybe I'm just weird or just too young yet lol. Effects people differently. I defintely dont get the coffee jitters either. Did an all day sit saturday and had 2 cups before I left for the woods and put the rest of the pot in two travel mugs. Drank the 30oz mug in the stand a few sips out of the EWO mug towards the end. Never did have to take a bathroom break though I felt one was coming the last few hours and still didnt go till I got home around 7pm
I normally drink a LOT of coffee on a daily basis, I'd say too much but I don't think that exists lol! I do have to pee more when I drink more, but that's it... No jitters here until after maybe my 8th or 9th large cup, and then I can feel it, but my hand stays steady. To re-phrase, I don't drink too much fluid in general "on stand". Hiking, different story!
 
Would you please describe areas of no use to deer? I've heard it said before to be on the lookout for saddles, pinch points, etc. when reviewing topo maps and satellite imagery but I've never really thought about negating areas because they'd be of little use to a deer.

I would believe that desirable areas for deer offer browse, feed trees, agriculture fields, creek crossings, Streamside Management Zones, transition areas, edge, cover for bedding, etc. Scouting reveals sign in the forms of ground disturbance under and around food sources as well as trails, in regards to traveling to and from bedding areas or food sources. Fresh deer droppings, rubs & scrapes indicate travel areas as well as an active food source. All of that and more can add up to high percentage hunts.

Non desirable areas offer little to anything that's mentioned above.
 
how aggressive are you? Are you confirming bedding areas during season by walking through them and seeing the beds or are you identifying based on travel observation and ''that thick area is most likely bedding"
 
@Nutterbuster am I allowed to continue targeted conversation here to drill down a little further or do I need to start my own thread? Specifically, I'd like to get these folks read on the meaning of a specific type of "hot sign".
Wouldnt be a bad idea to start a thread on it. I deal with this a lot in trapping where some or a lot of sign is deceptive and isnt worth setting on. Asking yourself "why is this sign here?" is a good question to ask yourself when you find it.
 
@Nutterbuster am I allowed to continue targeted conversation here to drill down a little further or do I need to start my own thread? Specifically, I'd like to get these folks read on the meaning of a specific type of "hot sign".
Exactly what this thread is for. Asking questions of qualified individuals. Drill away.
 
Following up on my poop theme here... I've always been confused about poop as an indicator of where deer WILL BE in the future. Historically for me, this "hot sign" I've heard so much about, has only been an indicator that I'm probably 10-20 minutes BEHIND a deer. How does one use fresh poop as an indicator predicting where those deer will be in the future? Or to put it another way, how does one effectively mentally process the information/situations below to effect a high percentage encounter?

A. I just walked up on steaming raisonettes under an oak in an oak flat. It is 1700 and the sun sets in 1 hour. Do I setup here? Will they be back before dark?

B. I just walked up on steaming raisonettes under an oak in an oak flat. It is 1400 and the sun sets in 4 hours. Do I setup here or continue walking? Will they be back before dark?

C. I just walked up on steaming raisonettes in a turnip field completely surrounded by woods. It is 0930. Do I setup here or continue walking?

@BTaylor brought up a good point. I am only concerned with getting on any available deer right now and not just a mature buck.
 
Lot of context needed as to whether they are in feeding areas, bedding areas, or travel corridors.

Deer tend to circle. Fresher the sign, the longer it will be before they return obviously. So for that same deer, I would try to setup for that time of day tomorrow. Finding steamers in the morning, theres a good chance theyll come back in the evening. If you find droppings in ag areas, I would work back to cover unless you're using a long range gun because once they get into the open they tender to wander all over the place.
 
A. Maybe, prolly not the one that left the pile
B. Maybe, maybe
C. Keep waking but maybe return

For A and B a steaming pile is just one piece information. Have to evaluate each spot on its merits. Are there a lot of acorns on the ground but only a pile or two of really fresh poop? That tree could be just turning on and could be good hunting for several days. Is it mostly caps and hulls with only a few acorns but several piles of poop of varying age? That tree is likely winding down in preference. Where are the trees in relation to bedding cover? Is there a discernable reason to believe this food spot is in or adjacent to a travel pattern or is it just a hot tree out in the middle of big open mature timber?

For C sure you can kill them in the plot, most effectively generally in the evenings but access and educating the herd can be an issue. Where are they bedding and are there features that define their travel to and from that would allow you to hunt them in transition to hopefully reduce educating them to the fact you have bad intentions. Especially if those spots are in relation to the west side or in a low spot or corner where they can have shade or cover from visibility.
 
Deer tend to circle. Fresher the sign, the longer it will be before they return obviously. So for that same deer, I would try to setup for that time of day tomorrow. Finding steamers in the morning, theres a good chance theyll come back in the evening. If you find droppings in ag areas, I would work back to cover unless you're using a long range gun because once they get into the open they tender to wander all over the place.
Have to evaluate each spot on its merits. Are there a lot of acorns on the ground but only a pile or two of really fresh poop? That tree could be just turning on and could be good hunting for several days. Is it mostly caps and hulls with only a few acorns but several piles of poop of varying age? That tree is likely winding down in preference. Where are the trees in relation to bedding cover? Is there a discernable reason to believe this food spot is in or adjacent to a travel pattern or is it just a hot tree out in the middle of big open mature timber?

For C sure you can kill them in the plot, most effectively generally in the evenings but access and educating the herd can be an issue. Where are they bedding and are there features that define their travel to and from that would allow you to hunt them in transition to hopefully reduce educating them to the fact you have bad intentions. Especially if those spots are in relation to the west side or in a low spot or corner where they can have shade or cover from visibility.
Great information here guys. Thank you very much. So for both responses (@SNIPERBBB and @BTaylor) sounds like the correct answer for A and B is to keep going because those deer are likely not going to return before sundown. How do you increase from "Maybe" to "Definitely"? Come back tomorrow but be at that location an hour earlier?

[Edit: It's not hard to find a set of deer tracks and follow them until you find freshly dropped poop.] I'm just trying to understand how to read fresh poop because I've mostly gotten the vibe that when you find fresh poop next to a pile of acorns that's the "hot sign" you've been looking for so go ahead and sit down and wait.
 
Last edited:
Great information here guys. Thank you very much. So for both responses (@SNIPERBBB and @BTaylor) sounds like the correct answer for A and B is to keep going because those deer are likely not going to return before sundown. How do you increase from "Maybe" to "Definitely"? Come back tomorrow but be at that location an hour earlier?

[Edit: It's not hard to find a set of deer tracks and follow them until you find freshly dropped poop.] I'm just trying to understand how to read fresh poop because I've mostly gotten the vibe that when you find fresh poop next to a pile of acorns that's the "hot sign" you've been looking for so go ahead and sit down and wait.
Time of day when you find hot sign is going to determine for me whether I go ahead and hunt or prep it for the next day. If it is late in the day then I will prolly drop a pin and get out of the area as quickly and quietly as I can and hopefully not booger it up for the next day. Otherwise, I am going to hang that day if it is fresh poop and the other boxes are checked. If you are hunting from the ground and have an hour of light left, I would make a hunt if there is cover to tuck into in range. I just dont really hunt from the ground often.
 
Back
Top