I have an Xstand climber that weighs 11lbs or 12 with shooting rail. I only switched to using a saddle for most hunts due to the bulk of carrying the stand and not being able to always hunt the best tree for a spot. Comfort varies per person and either works well, but my torn disc feels better in a saddle than sitting normal.
I honestly can climb as fast as any saddle method with my stand, blindfolded. Disclaimer - I will not use a harness and never have with any climbers in the past years, so I am super fast without having to deal with it. Don't do what I do!
When it is all said and done, except for a few fanatics, the saddle is just one tool in our hunting options that allows us to kill deer and other animals. I will use saddles, xstand, box blinds, gillies, ground blinds, ladder stands, and a broken down tractor in the course of my season. If I knew dressing like a scarecrow and standing in the corn field would work, I would do that too!
Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk