I'm a believer, when it come to deer movement due to different moon positions. I also believe that in regards to hunting deer nothing can be considered a 100% thing. Too many variables exist that create negatives to the normal. I've maintained what has become a detailed deer hunting journal since the 1968 season. It started off pretty simple through the first 8 season so I'm missing data that I've recorded since then. I know for a fact (not counting this season) while sitting on a stand 8,980 hours during 3,537 hunts I've enjoyed 6,520 deer sightings and didn't have a deer sighting during 1,832 hunts.
In regards to moon position, I knew that I had twice as many recorded deer sightings during the first and last moon quarters than I did during the new moon and full moon combined. I just couldn't figure out why until Jeff Murray came out with the Deer Hunters Moon Guide. Comparing his guide to my sightings, I realized that during the first quarter & last quarter the moon position is basically overhead or under foot during the early mornings & late evenings... Prime Time. And, during the new & full moon the moon position is basically overhead or under foot during the mid day.... Bedding Area Time.
During the years after I started using the moon position times, I've been amazed at how many times that it has proven to be accurate. I consider it another tool to aid in having more deer sightings.