You take gun or bow

[Blinginpse]

Ive never hunted out of state so i dint know how the tags work, but would you have more options for other game with one of the two weapons?

Say the moose tags cost the same. Is there a difference in/option for an additional wolf/bear/caribou/etc tag with a gun vs bow?

My opinion would be to take whichever gave you the most opportunity to stack up critters, if thats an option. In my state i just buy a license and they give tags out, so i rarely "target" animals i just go hunt and anything in season is fair game.

Na only option extra would he a bear tag and id not.waste the money for 1 them worthless things lol

Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

 

[Nutterbuster]

I'd take gun. Unless I took a gun, in which case I would take a gun

 

[ericabbott]

Bow 100%

 

[Topdog]

There is a group of guys in my town that have been going to Newfoundland for many years on Moose trips, they have to ride back in on track machines like they use for snowmobile groomers, apparently it’s a rough ride, they use rifles and from there “stories” always describe super long shots and I am assuming somewhat open country, some brush they call Tuck? that is knee high and wicked thick, there guide makes them wear wool for sneaking through that brush.

 

[Blinginpse]

There is a group of guys in my town that have been going to Newfoundland for many years on Moose trips, they have to ride back in on track machines like they use for snowmobile groomers, apparently it’s a rough ride, they use rifles and from there “stories” always describe super long shots and I am assuming somewhat open country, some brush they call Tuck? that is knee high and wicked thick, there guide makes them wear wool for sneaking through that brush.

Fella.whoni met on a forum several years ago i.talk.to has been 3.times. says its perfect for bowhunting. So.it all.may vary in area

Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

 

[DB4x4]

If there are no season/weapon limitations, I would take a gun for extended range, personal protection, and a better chance at a quick, ethical kill. I have taken deer with bow, xbow, gun, and flintlock muzz. To me, what makes a hunt memorable is the whole cumulative experience - Who I am with, the scenery, watching the animal, the adventure aspect, etc. I don't get too hung up on what I used to harvest. I take whatever gives me the best chance for that particular season. Critters already have an advantage in most sensory categories and they have home field advantage too.

I understand the excitement and challenge of the bow, but I guess it is just different for me. Some of my most memorable hunts were days where I didn't even get anything. Hunting a new area, trying a new strategy, watching or helping someone else get something, etc. In the end, it is YOUR hunt though, so go with your gut.

 

[Aaronpaul14]

Too bad it’s not a 2:1 guided trip. You could take the shot if it comes in bow range and if not let your buddy smoke it from a distance. Plus it’s more fun with a buddy around to share the experience with. Better stories back home if those stories are shared/witnessed.

Either way it will be a once in a lifetime experience!

 

[Kurt]

Dang man, that's not even a question! ......................Are you gonna make me say it?..................BOW ALL DAY!!!

 

[aclawrence]

Take the rifle!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[woodsdog2]

That's a super tough call. If you want somewhat of the challenge of a bow but some assurance of tagging out, maybe an open sight big bore lever action or something like that where it requires you to maybe get within 50 to 75 yards? Maybe a ML? I agree with a previous poster, the experience you are looking for truly is the only thing that can guide your thought process. What would I do? If I knew I might be able to afford another moose hunt opportunity someday, I would probably take my bow. $11,000 isn't a slight sum for most of us. Good luck with what ever decision you make. I think you should consider yourself blessed either way and just have a great time!!!