I t
Like most things in life it's not "All or nothing", It's a discussion. You can see in the picture above that some clothes glow and some clothes don't. Some deer might react and some might not. I think we all agree that if a deer notices something out of place, especially a mature deer, it's not going to stick around long.
Personally, I don't think that understanding a deer's vision is much different then understanding their behavior during the rut, or where they feed, or how well they can smell. I for one would hate to spend all season scouting and patterning a mature buck, put myself in the right spot at the right time, only to have him peg me in the tree 40 yards out (when I know I didn't move) and watch him turn and walk out of my life, to be left to wonder if I would have just bought a different detergent would I have killed that deer? If I remember correctly, that's exactly what happened to my dad 30 years ago when he started wondering about UV brighteners.
I think everyone draws their own lines as far as the ways they choose or don’t choose to limit themselves. Really I could make an argument that the decision to eliminate all UV or all scent from your clothes is similar to deciding to use a rifle as opposed to a bow, or a trad bow as opposed to a compound.
It’s all about how we choose to play the game. There’s something to be said for keeping it simple. One guy chooses a bow over a crossbow because he wants the extra challenge of getting the bow back without getting busted. For some other guy even a compound doesn’t feel right to him, he chooses a longbow that’s he knows he’s only good to 17 yards with. Another guy may choose to sit over top of a corn pile with a .270, in a heated box blind, sitting in a lazy boy.
As long as none of the above are breaking laws it’s all good. Each guy draws his own lines. My other post wasn’t meant to be mean spirited. Hope it didn’t come across that way. If it did, I apologize.
Do UV brightened clothes hurt my chances? I don’t know. I want new hunters to know that they don’t have to have all this extra stuff to kill deer. In fact, they don’t have to have it to kill nice bucks either. The hunting industry, whether it’s on purpose or not, tells young or new hunters that they have to have “X” product and if they don’t they aren’t serious hunters. The hunter ends up disappointed when he gets busted and wonders, “how do these deer keep seeing me, I used the product to take out UV, I must need to buy more and wash more often.”
The only real tool besides a weapon is right between the hunters ears.