Just coming off of a meetup I put together in Wisconsin. I’ve been using an XC for 3 years so I’m a fan. Tried a Buzzard Roost, Overwatch Outdoors Orion, Latitude Method 2, TX5 Lonestar, Trophyline, Outdoor Made Agile.
After the meetup, I personally have no reason to switch from the XC. I share the comments above about the waist buckle being flimsy on the older XC’s but the new XC’s that are shipping have a stiffer waist belt.
The Outdoor Made Agile was getting a lot of buzz at the meetup for comfort. It is super light and packable also. They only do internal load testing and it is constructed out of a nylon material so I wonder about durability and safety. This is a brand new company and saddle so time will tell. Price is only $200 so might be an appealing option for a lot of guys on a budget.
The Overwatch Outdoor Orion gets the nod for quality.
@JCLINE84 craftsmanship is second to none. You will not find a single lose thread or a stitch out of place on that rig and it can come with many personal options for waist belt, leg straps and seat material since they arecustom builds right now.
I had heard quite a bit of “buzz” about Buzzard Roost going into the meetup so I was excited to try that out. Benny Greggoire is a super nice dude and their support was great. This is a 2 panel saddle with straps to “lock” the panels in place. The saddle was comfortable but I’m just not a 2 panel guy. Biggest negative comment I heard on the buzzard was the leg loop design. Loops were removable so that is one remedy but for those that like to use loops, they involved feeding through a loop out on the hips, doubling back over and clipping back into a loop on the inner thigh. The shape of the bottom cut on the saddle didn’t fit the shape of my bottom half so I got some bunching when I cinched down the leg straps.
I was also excited to try out the TX5 Lonestar. I found it comfortable but need more time in it. The front of the saddle where the bridge loops connect is very structurally rigid to the point where it rode up into my lower ribs a little. It is also a very well constructed saddle.
i didn’t spend much time in the trophyline. It is too bulky and heavy for my personal liking.
So, my 4th season coming in a CRUZR XC with no regrets. Good luck out there.