I can't speak for the other sticks you mentioned but I've have beast sticks for 2 seasons. Like others have said they aren't the lightest or pack the smallest, but they are rock solid on a tree and have almost no flex. I've tried wild edge steps, SRT, Shikars, climbing spurs, and drill/bolts and keep coming back to beast sticks because there is no fiddle factor and have never felt unsafe while climbing with them. 3 beast sticks with amsteel rope mod and a naider/swaider and scout platform on the top stick weights 7.5 lbs and gets me to 20 feet.