• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

Canoe vs Kayak

Well I got 2 canoes Sunday 1 for $100 and 1 for $150 both or Northfork Wenonah 16' 9". Bought from a canoe rental place that was upgrading some of there fleet. They are well used but seem to be pretty solid. They are red>anybody tried painting one?
 
Well I got 2 canoes Sunday 1 for $100 and 1 for $150 both or Northfork Wenonah 16' 9". Bought from a canoe rental place that was upgrading some of there fleet. They are well used but seem to be pretty solid. They are red>anybody tried painting one?
LMK if you have a good painting method.
I got a 16FT Coleman Scanoe this past Friday.
Going to give it some TLC and get this thing on the water.
 
Anybody heard of a Wenonah? good or bad?

Wenonah kevlar canoes are excellent canoes for Boundary Waters trips. They are lightweight, stable, durable, handle well, and are easy to portage. I like them a lot.

That said I would not recommend one as an all-purpose boat for a novice canoer, or for hunting. Kevlar boats are downright fragile compared to Royalex or aluminum. They need to be loaded and boarded floating in enough water to prevent damage - read up on "wet-foot vs dry-foot canoes".

I have an old 12' Field and Stream Kay-Noe - essentially a cheaper Old town Pack 12' solo canoe. It's my go-to fishing boat. I've (unsuccessfully) hunted deer from it and gone camping in it.

If I were looking for a hunting canoe I would get a Royalex (or comprable synthetic) canoe 13'-16' long with bench (not racing-style) seats. Sit backwards in the rear seat, put your pack in front of you, and it will do everything you ask.

In my opinion, Kevlar is too fragile for stands and antlers, costs several times what aluminum and plastic boats cost, and degrades from UV radiation. Aluminum is too noisy and heavy, but lasts forever. A 12' solo boat like mine fills up too fast and handles poorly with a load - and will not take a passenger in any comfort, for any time. A kayak just doesn't have the storage capacity that a canoe offers. A generic, all-purpose, reasonably-lightweight plastic boat is by far my preference for this application.
 
Pictures of these steal of a deals you got @CooterBrown

You may need to screenshot them in order to upload the pictures. You said they are used, will they be needing any patch work?

@Weldabeast has a excellent thread where he refurbs a canoe that you may want to check out.
 
I haven't put them in the water yet but they don't appear to need any patching done. Ill try to take pics sometime this week.
 
Wenonah kevlar canoes are excellent canoes for Boundary Waters trips. They are lightweight, stable, durable, handle well, and are easy to portage. I like them a lot.

That said I would not recommend one as an all-purpose boat for a novice canoer, or for hunting. Kevlar boats are downright fragile compared to Royalex or aluminum. They need to be loaded and boarded floating in enough water to prevent damage - read up on "wet-foot vs dry-foot canoes".

I have an old 12' Field and Stream Kay-Noe - essentially a cheaper Old town Pack 12' solo canoe. It's my go-to fishing boat. I've (unsuccessfully) hunted deer from it and gone camping in it.

If I were looking for a hunting canoe I would get a Royalex (or comprable synthetic) canoe 13'-16' long with bench (not racing-style) seats. Sit backwards in the rear seat, put your pack in front of you, and it will do everything you ask.

In my opinion, Kevlar is too fragile for stands and antlers, costs several times what aluminum and plastic boats cost, and degrades from UV radiation. Aluminum is too noisy and heavy, but lasts forever. A 12' solo boat like mine fills up too fast and handles poorly with a load - and will not take a passenger in any comfort, for any time. A kayak just doesn't have the storage capacity that a canoe offers. A generic, all-purpose, reasonably-lightweight plastic boat is by far my preference for this application.
These canoes I got are not kevlar. They are the Northfork model made with "Three-Phase Rotomolded Construction method" with polyethylene. What are your views about this kind of canoe?
 
Pictures of these steal of a deals you got @CooterBrown

You may need to screenshot them in order to upload the pictures. You said they are used, will they be needing any patch work?

@Weldabeast has a excellent thread where he refurbs a canoe that you may want to check out.
I have the hardest time finding threads(must be doing something wrong) @Weldabeast if you can post a link that would be great
 
 
Thanks
 
If you can find a square-back canoe, you can have the best of both worlds. A 2.5 Suzuki is cheap and weighs 29 lbs. and load capacity is generally higher for canoes. My old plastic square-back has a 950lb rating.
 
I soaked myself trying to wade back from a new spot in the dark this past weekend. I rolled the dice on a deeper part of the river and lost. Went out and bought a 14' Sun Dolphin Scout for $300 from a local sporting goods store the next day!

I'm looking forward to a quiet, leisurely paddle to my hunting location next weekend :)
 
These canoes I got are not kevlar. They are the Northfork model made with "Three-Phase Rotomolded Construction method" with polyethylene. What are your views about this kind of canoe?

The only Wenonah boats I've paddled are kevlars; however, they are a high-quality reputable brand. It looks like the Northfork is a 16'9" boat - that might be tough to singlehand, but it will have the right seats for it. I won't hijack this thread with a dissertation on solo canoe technique so i will suffice to say you made an excellent purchase.
 
467A7CFA-58C2-4CBB-A7F4-AA07819E5C7D.png
 

Attachments

  • 4B438514-0AA8-404F-91A4-B5DE8574FBA3.png
    4B438514-0AA8-404F-91A4-B5DE8574FBA3.png
    773.3 KB · Views: 36
  • AD8947CD-A83E-4FD8-A172-F58B013C1376.png
    AD8947CD-A83E-4FD8-A172-F58B013C1376.png
    880 KB · Views: 36
  • 93C2C10A-C285-488D-923D-92383DBC68E2.png
    93C2C10A-C285-488D-923D-92383DBC68E2.png
    935.9 KB · Views: 37
  • 820CB657-EE53-416B-9BDD-DED9A59F247C.png
    820CB657-EE53-416B-9BDD-DED9A59F247C.png
    1.1 MB · Views: 37
I got one for $100 that's 500% in better shape than that one.
 
Back
Top