I decided I had to make the switch away from muck / lacrosse boots after my first out of state public land hunt in the hill country of SE Ohio... rubber boots really f'd me up. Following that trip I talked to guys frequently heading out west on elk hunts and this was the most frequently recommended boot among those I spoke to. Made a bunch of trips to stores that carried various brands (Kenetrek, Zamberlan, Crispi, HanWag, Salomon, Danner, Lowa, Scarpa, etc... even Keen) and kept on looking until I found a boot that felt amazing to MY FEET.
Ended up with the Crispi Birksdal uninsulated for my go to hunting boot. Only exception is when hunting an area where rubber boots are essential, such as a swampy or marshy areas. I am able to regulate foot temperature with high quality socks and surprisingly, have less issues with my feet getting cold during late season than I've ever had with rubber boots.
I also have a pair of the Crispi Avante Mid (goretex) I use in early season and scouting. Really like them but just don't cut it for late season but are much better than the Birksdals during early season.
Best recommendation I have is to keep an open mind and try as many makes/models as you can find access to. Make notes for comparison, make multiple trips if necessary, and don't settle until you find a pair that feel amazing on your feet and address your needs (support, rigidity/flex, weight, etc)... YOUR FEET may absolute love a lower priced boot and hate a higher priced boot or the exact opposite. Budget matters but don't think a high priced or even a low priced boot will answer your needs just because it fits yiur budget. Everyones feet are different and you may find you get uncomfortable pressure points in a boot that all of your buddies swear by. But if your feet aren't comfortable, long hikes through tough terrain into an all day sit during prime time won't be enjoyable. Just find the boot that works best for you and if it is out of your budget at the time, start saving, and keep rocking the boots you have until you have enough tucked away to buy the boots you want because your feet told you they were the ones....
Originally, I was hell bent on a particular Salomon boot because I thought for sure it was "the one". After finally getting my feet into a pair, they were not comfortable on my feet at all. Ended up taking me two years to finally settle on the Crispi Birksdal boots but after two seasons of use in various types of terrain and over 150 miles of walking, I don't regret it at all. Only have some minor scratches in the leather from thorns but other than that, still in great condition.
Whatever you end up with, just have to take care of them such as keeping them clean after use and conditioning the leather (if you chose leather). If you take care of them, they'll take care of you.
Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk