Hard to say; this is the only one I've used. The mesh is sturdy but soft, so I'm sure it's quieter than the cheap ones, and the seat is big and comfy. It's rock solid when kneeling, but when sitting with it collapsed with just your feet on the ground, having 3 points of contact helps, like your back against a tree. Otherwise, toppling over is a possibility. I've only done that once, but I'm sure it would have been hilarious to onlookers.Would you say this seat is way more comfortable than the standard cheap 3 legged stool? Seems like having this larger seat area than the cheapo stools would really increase the comfort factor. Also, how do you like sitting while the stool is collapsed down all the way for hunting behind some short cover?