I did some testing because I'm a data nerd. The testing used the same piece of oplux rope.
Finished length:
Rope (no knots) = 109" or 9' 1"
Triple fishermans w/ overhand = 96" or 8'
Figure 8 on a bight w/ double fishermans safety = 71" or 5' 11"
Just on length alone, there are advantages as you use over 2 feet less rope with this over a figure 8. That'll save you a few bucks per tether but also makes for a more compact kit, especially with larger diameter ropes.
Speed and cleanliness:
Negligible. Tying an overhand or cow hitch is about as quick as feeding the tag end through the bight. Some advantage may go to this over the figure 8 as you can keep you rope off the ground easier.
Wear:
It occurred to me last night that on my tethers last season, I tied the figure 8 and left it alone. In effect, I used it the same as a sewn eye. However, both tethers have developed a flat area right at the pinch point because no matter the tree diameter, that spot will always take 100% of the directional load. Once massaged, the sheath and core still feel good but it's a data point.
With this method, tying the overhand or cow hitch every time will change the stress points in the rope and should in theory make for a safer and longer lasting rope. The triple fishermans wouldn't be retied but due to it's limited stresses (it's just there as a safety), that shouldn't matter.
Finished length:
Rope (no knots) = 109" or 9' 1"
Triple fishermans w/ overhand = 96" or 8'
Figure 8 on a bight w/ double fishermans safety = 71" or 5' 11"
Just on length alone, there are advantages as you use over 2 feet less rope with this over a figure 8. That'll save you a few bucks per tether but also makes for a more compact kit, especially with larger diameter ropes.
Speed and cleanliness:
Negligible. Tying an overhand or cow hitch is about as quick as feeding the tag end through the bight. Some advantage may go to this over the figure 8 as you can keep you rope off the ground easier.
Wear:
It occurred to me last night that on my tethers last season, I tied the figure 8 and left it alone. In effect, I used it the same as a sewn eye. However, both tethers have developed a flat area right at the pinch point because no matter the tree diameter, that spot will always take 100% of the directional load. Once massaged, the sheath and core still feel good but it's a data point.
With this method, tying the overhand or cow hitch every time will change the stress points in the rope and should in theory make for a safer and longer lasting rope. The triple fishermans wouldn't be retied but due to it's limited stresses (it's just there as a safety), that shouldn't matter.