• The SH Membership has gone live. Only SH Members have access to post in the classifieds. All members can view the classifieds. Starting in 2020 only SH Members will be admitted to the annual hunting contest. Current members will need to follow these steps to upgrade: 1. Click on your username 2. Click on Account upgrades 3. Choose SH Member and purchase.
  • We've been working hard the past few weeks to come up with some big changes to our vendor policies to meet the changing needs of our community. Please see the new vendor rules here: Vendor Access Area Rules

Tethrd One Sticks Gen 2

Plebe

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Sep 14, 2020
5,991
10,263
113
44
Junkers in high end luxury box packaging.
Karma is a boomerang.

Lol. Boomerang for sure.

Won't be long before all the happy customers get their sticks back and the story turns to how Tethrd did the right thing and it wasn't really necessary because these sticks are actually super strong and awesome...a few bad apples campaign.

I'd love to know how many don't send them in for testing, that'd be super interesting.
 

enkriss

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Sep 13, 2018
6,114
8,964
113
42
Lol. Boomerang for sure.

Won't be long before all the happy customers get their sticks back and the story turns to how Tethrd did the right thing and it wasn't really necessary because these sticks are actually super strong and awesome...a few bad apples campaign.

I'd love to know how many don't send them in for testing, that'd be super interesting.

I didn’t send mine back for testing.

I sent them turds back for a refund.
 

Plebe

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Sep 14, 2020
5,991
10,263
113
44
I didn’t send mine back for testing.

I sent them turds back for a refund.

Fair enough. You know what I meant though.

But as you mention it, what do you think happens to them "turds"?
 

iamcorey

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2018
2,716
2,576
113
Tethrd is getting roasted on every hunting forum, facebook page, everywhere, why and heck wouldn’t they just post a short youtube video on how exactly they are testing these sticks, what they are looking for, and a brief explanation of the whole situation, nothing cutesy just speak the truth and put some of these fires out, damage is done already…obviously.. but if this was my business I would be communicating a lot better than this, I’m sure the video would set off another firestorm of people judging the whole process but at this point what is there to lose, I’m sure they are not legally obligated to post a video like that, but lets be honest they made a business by exploiting the awesome power of the internet..facebook..youtube..this forum.. one would think if they have any chance of moving forward after this latest debacle some more transparency is needed, but hey what do I know, I’ve only been in business 20 years and see know change in my future..

Roasted? Yes.

Expensive for them? Depends on contracts and root cause.

Good news is that the average attention span is short, and brand marketing with a sprinkle of spin has proven VERY effective in the past. This is but the latest storm to weather for them. Once the carbon platform is released, everyone will be hitting the F5 key waiting for stock to consume. And so it goes…


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

enkriss

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Sep 13, 2018
6,114
8,964
113
42
Roasted? Yes.

Expensive for them? Depends on contracts and root cause.

Good news is that the average attention span is short, and brand marketing with a sprinkle of spin has proven VERY effective in the past. This is but the latest storm to weather for them. Once the carbon platform is released, everyone will be hitting the F5 key waiting for stock to consume. And so it goes…


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

UnfortunateClearcutArrowana-max-1mb.gif
 

raisins

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Jan 17, 2019
6,284
8,115
113
47

I got a small carbon fiber splinter in my hand off a broken tennis racket. I still remember the unique pain. No way am I straddling a Tethrd-made carbon fiber platform.

Besides, I'm betting that with some 7075 aluminum that is heat treated after any welding and then some judicious use of fiberglass-reinforced nylon (or similar materials) in areas that aren't structural (like areas that are just for your boot to have traction on) that you could make a platform the size of a Predator that weighs 2 lbs or less. But you might need to take a different approach (maybe design a mild arch under the platform edge, etc).

Weird that it is sand casting or jump straight to carbon (or titanium in the case of the sticks) when it doesn't seem like what aluminum can do has even been approached.
 

Mopar1169

Well-Known Member
Feb 26, 2020
508
779
93
41
Central Michigan
I got a small carbon fiber splinter in my hand off a broken tennis racket. I still remember the unique pain. No way am I straddling a Tethrd-made carbon fiber platform.

Besides, I'm betting that with some 7075 aluminum that is heat treated after any welding and then some judicious use of fiberglass-reinforced nylon (or similar materials) in areas that aren't structural (like areas that are just for your boot to have traction on) that you could make a platform the size of a Predator that weighs 2 lbs or less. But you might need to take a different approach (maybe design a mild arch under the platform edge, etc).

Weird that it is sand casting or jump straight to carbon (or titanium in the case of the sticks) when it doesn't seem like what aluminum can do has even been approached.

7075 is considered a non weldable aluminum that is why it isn't used in alot of applications.
 

raisins

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Jan 17, 2019
6,284
8,115
113
47
7075 is considered a non weldable aluminum that is why it isn't used in alot of applications.

Huh...thanks for the info. Can you think of a way to use aluminum to its fullest and get light platforms without resorting to exotic materials?
 

thedutchtouch

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Oct 22, 2020
3,550
6,960
113
Maryland
I am no materials engineer but I find it hard to believe that there's not a composite out there that's better suited to this than carbon. Sure everyone thinks about carbon as light weight, but there's got to be some other plastic or urethane or resin/ester/don't have the right vocab here.... But like why not make a platform out of the urethane that steps are made from?
 

raisins

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Jan 17, 2019
6,284
8,115
113
47
I am no materials engineer but I find it hard to believe that there's not a composite out there that's better suited to this than carbon. Sure everyone thinks about carbon as light weight, but there's got to be some other plastic or urethane or resin/ester/don't have the right vocab here.... But like why not make a platform out of the urethane that steps are made from?

If true, this is super exciting not only for saddle hunting....but everything....super light cars, etc.

.
 

enkriss

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Sep 13, 2018
6,114
8,964
113
42
I am no materials engineer but I find it hard to believe that there's not a composite out there that's better suited to this than carbon. Sure everyone thinks about carbon as light weight, but there's got to be some other plastic or urethane or resin/ester/don't have the right vocab here.... But like why not make a platform out of the urethane that steps are made from?

Cuz for a platform the juice isn’t worth the squeeze. In order to get it structurally sound you will need more material than say a cast version of the platform to be equally as strong. Even though the plastic would be lighter in a 1:1 quantity you might need a 3:1 quantity of material negating any weight saving you were trying to get.

Carbon fiber is particularly attractive because it can be made stronger than other plastics because of the fiber reinforcement. For the most part in simple terms the more fiber content the stronger the item will be.
 

raisins

Well-Known Member
SH Member
Jan 17, 2019
6,284
8,115
113
47
Cuz for a platform the juice isn’t worth the squeeze. In order to get it structurally sound you will need more material than say a cast version of the platform to be equally as strong. Even though the plastic would be lighter in a 1:1 quantity you might need a 3:1 quantity of material negating any weight saving you were trying to get.

Carbon fiber is particularly attractive because it can be made stronger than other plastics because of the fiber reinforcement. For the most part in simple terms the more fiber content the stronger the item will be.

One thing is that standing at the edge of a platform without any other support for the platform (like wire rope, etc) puts a lot of strain on that structure.

If we don't want wire rope on saddle platforms to trip us up, then perhaps we can have a brace underneath (like a treehopper treesuit platform) but make is adjustable to allow for different platform angles. We could also keep the top adjustment screw on the predator and then you'd have support top and bottom. With this support going underneath in an arch like structure, then we might be able to cut some weight (or add it somewhere else?).

All I know is that a LocOn Windwalker being way bigger but only twice as heavy as a Tethrd Predator seems bananas.
 

n6dlh

Active Member
SH Member
Nov 27, 2020
168
188
43
43
Smithfield, VA
aerialedge.com
WEBSITE
http://aerialedgevirginia.com

I will be honest, back when the Predator had offset bolts and was cracking, I did not understand all the hate posts. I was not sure if it was just people being haters or just people that like to complain. Looked like a flaw that they were replacing when the issue arise. It seemed that their products were in use everywhere and the Predator Platform was kind of a golden standard. Fast forward to the recall. I waited over a year to get these sticks. I wanted to be sure the kinks from the first generations were worked out, payed top dollar for some sticks that are made in China. Weight being the biggest reason. Back problems will do that to people.

After getting the Gen 2 in, I had 2 in the box with significant lower step wobble. Then 3 days later the recall. I now understand the people that have been saying this for years. I cannot stand companies that have no quality control, and let their customers pay top dollar for the right to be Beta Testers. The fact that they were factory sealed boxes as evident from their shipping requirements when you placed the order means there was no one inspecting them or doing Quality Control once they opened the container. For something like climbing sticks that seems to be a bit reckless.

The only thing I can say is Tethrd did refund me completely, even for the stealth strips.
 

Mopar1169

Well-Known Member
Feb 26, 2020
508
779
93
41
Central Michigan
Huh...thanks for the info. Can you think of a way to use aluminum to its fullest and get light platforms without resorting to exotic materials?

They could use 7075 would just have to use bolts or some sort of fasteners to hold it all together. Not sure what the price difference is with it. It is a harder material so machining takes more time I think. It has twice the tensile and 1.5 times the shear of 6061 in a t6 heat treat. It is more brittle then 6061 though. So not sure if it will take flexing like 6061 does.
 
  • Like
Reactions: raisins

Weldabeast

Well-Known Member
SH Member
May 23, 2019
12,572
26,193
113
Northeast Florida
They could use 7075 would just have to use bolts or some sort of fasteners to hold it all together. Not sure what the price difference is with it. It is a harder material so machining takes more time I think. It has twice the tensile and 1.5 times the shear of 6061 in a t6 heat treat. It is more brittle then 6061 though. So not sure if it will take flexing like 6061 does.
Food for thought.....1x1 square stock 6061 is $11 a foot and same dimension in the 7000 series of aluminum $32 dollars a foot.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mopar1169